At the trade deadline, the focus is often on the rental market. Contending teams are looking for that final piece but want a short-term acquisition as they can’t afford to keep the player beyond the current season. However, some non-rentals also attract some interest at this time of year. It appears one of them is in Pittsburgh as Daily Faceoff’s Frank Seravalli reports that the Penguins are receiving a lot of calls on winger Reilly Smith, even more than Jake Guentzel, one of the top rentals potentially available between now and March 8th.
The 32-year-old was acquired by Pittsburgh last summer in a move that basically amounted to a salary cap dump from Vegas with Smith, an important part of their Stanley Cup run, yielding just a third-round pick in return. For a player who reached the 50-point mark in four of his six seasons with the Golden Knights, the return was on the light side but in a flat-cap environment, several teams had to make tough decisions like that.
While Penguins GM Kyle Dubas was hoping that Smith would be a key two-way contributor, that hasn’t exactly been the case. Instead, his offensive numbers are down as he has just 10 goals and 15 assists in 51 games so far, not a great return on a $5MM price tag. He’s still averaging over 16 minutes a night, however, and is seeing some action on the penalty kill. In terms of a player profile, Smith is the type of player a lot of teams can use.
Fitting that contract onto the books is difficult enough for this season with half the league currently using LTIR to stay salary cap-compliant. The fact that Smith has another year left on his deal after this one adds to the allure but also adds to the complications of making such a deal work.
Seravalli suggests that Smith could be a candidate for salary retention to help open up his market. Pittsburgh has two of their three slots left while the one they’ve used (Jeff Petry) is on the books through next season. If Dubas isn’t concerned about using a second slot through 2024-25, paying down Smith’s contract to just a $2.5MM AAV would certainly bolster his market and should allow them to get a considerably better return than what they gave up to get him. While it’s not the direction they were hoping for, it looks like Smith could help yield a quality piece for a potential rebuild or retool this offseason.